Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Characters of Vulnerability of Girls to Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children (CSEC): Case Studies in Lombok and Jakarta

Bagus Yaugo Wicaksono


The victims of commercial sexual exploitation of children (CSEC) -especially girls- both in Jakarta - and Lombok area are having unique characteristic of vulnerability, therefore in order to optimize supporting the victims, an understanding of these characteristics of vulnerability in both areas are required. The purpose of this article is to describe and analyze the implementation of Down to Zero Project conducted by Plan International Indonesia (PII) in North Jakarta, East Jakarta, West Lombok, and Central Lombok. By conducting desk review of documents and results of previous studies during the implementation of this project, this study argues that; first, on the one side, the vulnerability of CSEC victims in Lombok areas tends to have a relation with poverty, furthermore the strict norms and value of custom could be challenging. On the other side, ineffective protection from family or caregiver makes a huge challenge for CSEC victims in the Jakarta area, in addition a heterogenous society and individualist characters create ineffective social protection for them. Secondly, these differences showed that the existing child protection system for girl victims of CSEC is not fully able to support them to reach the quality of life.



commercial sexual exploitation of children (CSEC); girl child vulnerability; girl victim of CSEC

Full Text:



Abigail, C 2019, “Profil Korban ESKA 2019”, dokumen tim DtZ tidak

dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International Indonesia

Bassiouni, CM et al. 2010, “Addressing International Human

Trafficking In Women And Children For Commercial Sexual

Exploitation In The 21st Century”, Revue internationale de droit

penal, Vol. 81, h. 417-491

Bell, RE 2001, “Sex trafficking: A financial crime perspective”, Journal

of Financial Crime, 9(2), h. 165–177.,

Bruyere, E & Garbarino, J 2010, “The Ecological Perspective on the

Human Rights of Children”, From Child Welfare to Child Well-Being,


Carling, J 2008, Migration, human smuggling, and trafficking from

Nigeria to Europe, International Peace Research Institute Oslo,


Carpinteri, A. et al. 2018, “Commercial Sexual Exploitation of

Children: An Assessment of Offender Characteristics”, Journal

Society for Police and Criminal Psychology 33, h. 150–157

Dottridge, M 2008, “Young People’s Voices on Child Trafficking:

Experiences from South Eastern Europe”, Innocenti Working Paper

No. IWP-2008-05, UNICEF Innocenti Research Centre, Florence.

ECPAT 2016a, “Draft Laporan Penelitian Eksploitasi Seksual

Komersial Anak (Eska) Di Nustenggara Barat”, dokumen tim DtZ

tidak dupublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International Indonesia

ECPAT 2016b, “Penelitian Eksploitasi Seksual Komersial Anak (Eska)

Di Dki Jakarta”, dokumen tim DtZ tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan

International Indonesia

ECPAT 2017, Online Child Sexual Exploitation: An Analysis of

Emergingand Selected Issues, diakses pada 4 Mei 2020, https://www.

Eddyono SW, Hendra R & Budiman AA 2017, Melawan Praktik

Prostitusi Anak di Indonesia dan Tantangannya, ICJR, Jakarta.

Eddyono, SW & Singereta, E 2016, Penanganan Kasus Eksploitasi

Seksual Komersial Anak (ESKA) di Indonesia Belajar dari Pengalaman

Penanganan Perkara Kasus-Kasus ESKA di Indonesia, ICJR, Jakarta.

Estes, RJ & Weiner, NA 2001, The commercial sexual exploitation of

children in the U. S., Canada, and Mexico, University of Pennsylvania,

School of Social Work, Philadephia.

Fauzi, A & Zarzani TR 2018, “The Development of Child Commercial

Sex Exploitation (CSEC):Response Model In Medan City”, Journal of

Community Research and Service, Vol.1 No.2. h. 83-91

Firdaus, A 2018, “The Criminal Responsibility on the Under Age

Children Exploitation in Indonesia”, Advances in Sosial Science,

Education and Humanities Research, Atlantis Press, volume 192.

Garbarino, J 1992, Children and families in the sosial environment

(2nd ed.), Aldine de Gruyter, New York.

Greenbaum, VJ 2014, “Commercial sexual exploitation and sex

trafficking of children in the United States”, Current Prob Ped Adol

Health Care, Vo. 44 No. 9, h.245-269.

Hidayat, R 2015, “Kajian Bentuk- Bentuk Eksploitasi Seks

Komersial Anak di Lingkungan Wisata Provinsi Sulawesi Utara”,

Sosiohumaniora, Vol.18 No.3, h. 243 – 252.

Inayanti, E, Shaluhiyah, Z, & Widjanarko, B 2015, “Karakteristik Anak

yang Rawan Terjerat Eksploitasi Seksual Komersial: Studi Kasus di

Surabaya Bekerjasama dengan LSM Abdi Asih Surabaya”, Jurnal

Promosi Kesehatan Indonesia, Vol. 10 No. 1. h. 47-61

Kartikawati, R 2016, “Fenomena AYLA (Anak Yang Dilacurkan)”

diakses 28 Mei 2020,

Kimhur, B 2020, “How to Apply the Capability Approach to Housing

Policy? Concepts, Theories and Challenges”, Journal Housing,

Theory and Society, DOI: 10.1080/14036096.2019.1706630.

Klatt, T, Cavner, D, & Egan, V 2014, “Rationalising predictors of child

sexual exploitation and sex-trading”, Child Abuse & Neglect, Vol. 38,

h. 252–260.

Kleist, C 2020, “Global Ethics: Capabilities Approach”. Internet

Encyclopedia of Philosophy: A Peer-reviewed Academic Resources,

diakses 14 Mei 2020,

Kristiningsih, D & Kasuma, I 2018, “Settlement of Online Child Sexual

Exploitation Cases in Indonesia (Cases Study: Facebook Group

‘Club Brondong Puncak’ and ‘Official Candy’s Group’)”, PEOPLE:

International Journal of Sosial Sciences, 4(3), h. 482-495.

Miller-Perrin, C & Wurtele, SK 2017, “Sex Trafficking and the

Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children”, Women & Therapy,

:1-2, h. 123-151.

Nathan, D 2017, “Analyzing and Measuring Vulnerability: An Approach

with Special Reference to Mountain Areas”, Indian Journal of Human

Development, 11(1), 37–55. Doi:10.1177/0973703017715365.

Nussbaum, M 1999, “Women and equality: The capabilities

approach”, International Labour Review, Vol. 138 No. 3. h. 227-245

Nussbaum, M 2000, Women and human development: the capabilities

approach, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Peleg, N 2019, The child’s right to development, Cambridge University

Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom, USA.

Rahman, MA 2011, “Human trafficking in the era of globalization: the

case of trafficking in the global market economy”, Transcience Journal

(1), h. 54–71.

Ramdhany, LMW 2013, “Perlindungan Hukum Terhadap Anak Korban

Eksploitasi Seks Komersial (Studi di Polrestabes Surabaya)”, Fakultas

Hukum Universitas Brawijaya, diakses 14 Mei 2020, http://hukum.

Ramdlany, A & Munir, M 2011, “Perlindungan Hukum terhadap

Eksploitasi Seksual Komersial Anak”, Journal Pamator, Vol. 4 No. 2.

h. 188-195

Sarkar, S 2015, “Use of technology in human trafficking networks

and sexual exploitation: A cross-sectional multi-country study”,

Transnational Sosial Review, Vol. 5, No. 1, h. 55-68

Sen, A 1981, Poverty and famines, Oxford University Press, New


Sen, A 2009, The Idea of Justice, Belknap Press of Harvard University

Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Smith, LA. et al. 2009, “The national report on domestic minor sex

trafficking: America’s prostituted children”, Shared Hope International,

USA, diakses 15 Mei 2020


Sofian, A et al. 2016, “ Research on Sexual Exploitation and Abuse of

Children in Indonesia: A Study in DKI Jakarta, East Nusa Tenggara,

and West Nusa Tenggara, INDONESIA”, Yayasan Plan International

Indonesia, Jakarta

Sutinah, S & Kinuthia KW 2019, “Trafficking of Women and Children

in East Java, Indonesia”, Journal of International Women’s Studies,

(9), 94-106.

Tim DtZ 2016a, “Catatan FGD Baseline Studi DtZ Jakarta”, dokumen

tim DtZ tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International Indonesia

Tim DtZ 2016b, “Catatan FGD Baseline Studi DtZ Lombok”, dokumen

tim DtZ tidak dupublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International Indonesia

Tim DtZ 2017a, “Annual Report 2017”, DtZ Alliance, Netherland

Tim DtZ 2017b, “Kisah Inspiratif Proyek Down to Zero Jejak Kaki

Selama Dua Tahun (2016-2017)”, Yayasan Plan International,


Tim DtZ 2018a, “Catatan Akhir Tahun Project Down to Zero”, Yayasan

Plan International Indonesia, Jakarta

Tim DtZ 2018b, “Theory of Change DtZ tahun 2018” dokumen tim

DtZ Indonesia tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International


Tim DtZ 2019a, “Catatan Akhir Tahun Proyek Down to Zero:

Memerangi Eksploitasi Seksual Komersial Anak”, Yayasan Plan

International Indonesia, Jakarta

Tim DtZ 2019b, “Data base Penerima Manfaat Proyek DtZ tahun

”, dokumen tim DtZ tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan

International Indonesia

Tim DtZ 2019c, “Good Practice Poyek DtZ tahun 2019”, dokumen

tim DtZ tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International Indonesia

Tim MDF 2016, “Baseline Report: Down to Zero”, MDF Netherland,


Tim Yayasan Gagas 2016, “Situasi Analisis Hak Anak di desa

Wajageseng”, dokumen tim DtZ tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan

International Indonesia

Tim Yayasan Gagas 2018,”Case Story Anak Korban di Lombok”,

dokumen tim DtZ tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International


Tim Yayasan Gagas 2020, “Anak korban Lombok Barat”, dokumen

tim DtZ tidak dipublikasikan, Yayasan Plan International Indonesia

United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) 2014, “Hidden in plain

sight: A statistical analysis of violence against children”, UNICEF,

USA, diakses 15 Mei 2020


UNODC 2018, “Global Report on Trafficking in Persons 2018”,

United Nations publication, Viena, diakses 14 Mei 2020, http://www.

UNODC and the Thailand Institute of Justice (TIJ) 2017, “Trafficking in

persons from Cambodia, Lao PDR and Myanmar to Thailand”, UNODC, Bangkok, diakses 14 Mei 2020 http://www.downtozeroplatform.


Walker-Rodriguez, A & Hill, R 2011, “Human sex trafficking”, FBI

Law Enforcement Bill 80:1–9, diakses 2 Mei 2020 http://www.

Windari, R 2019, “Penanggulangan Eksploitasi Seksual Komersial

Anak (ESKA) Berdasarkan Global - Local Based Approach

(Glocalization)”, Soumatera Law Review, Vol.2 No. 2, h. 282-296

Zarzani, TR 2017, “Konsepsi Perlindungan Anak Dari Tindakan

Eksploitasi Seksual Komersial Anak Pada Hukum Internasional Dan

Penerapannya Dalam Hukum Nasional”, De Lega Lata, Vol.2 No. 2,

h. 398-417.


  • There are currently no refbacks.