Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Proliferation of Postfeminist-Postmasculine Imagery & Disarticulation of Equality Activism: A Classroom of Feminist Media Studies as Politics of Emancipation

Ratna Noviani


Since the end of 1990s, Indonesian media have been suddenly becoming feminists. It could be seen from the proliferation of images of what so-called “female individualism”. In this sense, women are depicted as being independent, success, beautiful and empowered. These images are followed by the rise of images of less superordinate and less powerful men than as previously required by patriarchal order. Subject-object relationship in terms of gender becomes fluid and interchangeable, as if the problem of inequality is already fixed and resolved. Such media images of postfeminism and postmasculinism are, in fact, disembedded and disconnected from the real problems of gender prevailed in the society. Those images tend to celebrate feminist success, but at the same time devaluing and negating feminist political activism. In this regard, integrating feminist perspectives into academic media studies in Indonesia becomes one of pivotal steps to challenge disarticulartion of feminism done via and by the media.


Postfeminism; postmasculinism; disarticulation; emancipation; feminist media studies

Full Text:



Adams, R & Savran, D (eds.) 2002, ‘Introduction’, dalam The

Masculinity Studies Reader, Blackwell Publishers, Massachussets &

Oxford UK. pp. 1-8

Beauvoir, SD 1956, The Second Sex, Jonathan Cape & Thirty Beadford

Square, London.

Beynon, J 2002, Masculinities and Culture, Open University Press,

Buckingham & Philadelphia.

Brod, H 2002, ‘Studying Masculinities as Superordinate Studies’

dalam JG Gardiner (ed.), Masculinity Studies and Feminist Theory,

Columbia University Press, New York, pp. 161-175.

Connell, RW 2005, Masculinities, 2nd edn, University of California

Press, Berkely, Los Angeles.

Craig, S 1992, ‘Introduction: Considering Men and the Media’ dalam

S Craig (ed.), Men Masculinity and the Media, Sage Publications,

Newsbury Park, London, New Delhi, pp. 1-8.

Dyer, R 2002, Only Entertainment, 2nd edn, Routledge, London & NY.

Friedan, B 1963, The Feminine Mistique, W.W. Norton and Company,

New York.

Gardiner, JK 2002, ‘Introduction’, dalam JK Gardiner (ed.). Masculinity

Studies and Feminist Theory, Columbia University Press, New York,

pp. 1-30.

Gill, R 2007, Gender and the Media, Polity, Cambridge, MA.

Goldman, R 1992, Reading Ads Socially, Routledge, London & NY.

Harris, G 2012, ‘A Return to Form? Postmasculinist Television Drama

and Tragic Heroes in the Wake of the Sopranos’, New Review of Film

and Television Studies, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 443-463.

Kimmel, MS 2002, ‘Foreword’, dalam JK Gardiner (ed.), Masculinity

Studies and Feminist Theory, Columbia University Press, New York,

pp. ix-xi.

Lesmana, Mira (Produser) & Reza, Riri (Sutradara) 2016. Ada Apa

dengan Cinta 2, Miles Production & Legacy Pictures, Jakarta

MacKinnon, K 2003, Representing Men: Maleness and Masculinity in

the Media, Arnold, London.

McRobbie, A 2009, The Aftermath of Feminisme: Gender, Culture and

Social Change, Sage Publications, LA, London, Thousand Oaks.

Mumford, M 2009, Bertolt Brecht, Routledge, London, New York.

Neale, S 1983, ‘Masculinity as Spectacle’, Screen, vol. 24, no. 6, pp.


Nilan, P 2009, ‘Contemporary Masculinities and Young Men in

Indonesia’, Indonesia and the Malay World, vol. 37, no. 109, pp. 327-

Pilcher, J & Whelehan, I 2004, 50 Concepts in Gender Studies, Sage

Publications, London, Thousand Oak, New Delhi.

Stuart, A 1990, ‘Feminism: Dead or Alive?’ dalam J Rutherford

(ed.), Identity: Community, Culture, Difference, Lawrence & Wishart,

London, pp. 28-42.


  • There are currently no refbacks.